Best baked beans to buy: expert taste test

Rating: 4.5/5

Yes, after trying all 14 different beans in the blind taste test, Heinz still came out on top as the winner and favourite from the judges. They give a familiar, comforting baked bean taste that feels nostalgic and reminded judges of childhood. A classic bean, although they are touch sweet compared to others that we tried.

Available from:
Tesco (£1.30/415g)
Sainsbury’s (£1.40/415g)

Aldi Bramwells baked beans

Rating: 4.5/5

The Aldi own-brand ‘Bramwells’ baked beans are a highly effective Heinz dupe – and just 41p a can. In the blind taste test, some judges suggested this could even be Heinz. The beans are in a rich tomato sauce with a subtle sweetness and great overall flavour.

Available from:
Aldi (41p/410g)

Bold Bean Co rich tomato baked beans

Rating: 4/5

A bougie bean option. The giant white beans are soft and creamy with a thick, passata-style sauce with a decent hit of herbs. These would still be great on toast at brunch but could also be added to stews and casseroles for instant depth of flavour.

Available from:
Waitrose (£3.50/325g)

Ocado baked beans

Rating: 4/5

If you’re making regular Ocado orders, try adding some of their own-brand beans to your next shop. These look great, have soft and creamy beans and a rich sauce.

Available from:
Ocado (43p/420g)

Lidl Newgate baked beans

Rating: 4/5

Another classic baked bean that some judges thought could be Heinz during the blind taste test. The beans are well cooked and seasoned, although there could be a stronger tomato flavour.

Available from:
Lidl (see in-store for price)

Branston baked beans

Rating: 4/5

Another classic bean offering, that some suggested tasted very similar to Heinz. It gave a familiar nostalgic flavour and was not as sweet as some others, which judges appreciated.

Available from:
Tesco (£1/410g)

Morrisons baked beans

Rating: 3.5/5

These have a good balance of sweetness without being too sugary. The beans are cooked well (although could be larger) and the sauce is slightly thin.

Available from:
Morrisons (42p/410g)

Enjoyed this? Check out more expert taste tests…

Best sticky toffee pudding
Best salt and vinegar crisps
Best coffee beans
Best meal delivery services
Best hampers
Best flavoured vodka
Best chocolate subscriptions and clubs
Best meat boxes
Best kombucha
Best healthy and vegan meal box subscriptions
Best protein powder